Monday, September 23, 2013

Charging the Battery, or Not So Much

It should have been a simple task. Get a solar PV panel, charge controller, and a lead-acid battery to support the electronics on my solar hot water system, but it wasn't .

The solar PV system on solar thermal hot water heater has never worked properly. The system struggles to charge the batteries which typically end up being dead by the time I get home from work in the evening. I know the batteries work properly, because if I charge them on an external charger, everything works fine. The batteries have more than enough energy to run the differential controller all night.  

Some Background
  Not wanting to plug my new solar powered solar hot water system into mains power, I purchased two 20 watt solar PV panels and mounted them next to the solar hot water panels.  But for the solar PV panels to do their job, they need both a charge controller and a battery.
 
   For the charge controller, I found this 10 AMP CMP12/24 unit on ebay.  Sure it is an inexpensive Chinese made unit, but none of the brand name people had much in the way of small charge controllers.  It seems to do the job. 


   The charge controller is intended to be paired with one or two 12 volt lead acid batteries.   In my experience, these batteries only last about 4 years, so I wanted to try something different.

    Eneloop NiMH batteries have been serving me well in other applications, so I thought I would give them a try in this application.  The question was, how many batteries would I need to simulate the 24 volts of two lead acid batteries.  Since these batteries are typically listed as 1.2 volt, simple math show 20 batteries × 1.2 volts = 24 volts.  Perfect, right?  perhaps not as we shall see.
Since the beginning of operation of solar hot water system, there has been a problem with startup in the morning.  There didn't seem to be enough energy in the batteries to have the controller up and running all night long.  Therefore in the morning, the exhausted battery pack couldn't open the zone valves.  Typically the differential controller would try to open zone valve, but as soon as current started to flow from the batteries, the battery pack voltage would dip below 21 volts and the charge control would kill the power to the load.  This setup a cycle that could repeat about every 20 seconds for quite a long time, where the valves would start to open and then the power would get cut..

Collecting the data.
     As is often the case in problem solving, the first thing that needed to happen was to collect data so the problem could be understood.  I have previously used the Hobo U12-4 data logger to record temperature data, and the same system is capable of recording voltages.  Unfortunately, the Hobo data logger can only record voltages between 0 and 2.5 V.  To record higher voltages required a special cable to be made with a 2.5 mm stereo plug and a voltage divider circuit between the center pin and the shield.  The voltage divider used a 1Kohm and a 22 Kohm resistor.  This resulted in a gain of 23× and made the range expand to between 0 and 57.5 volts.   This is a larger range then needed, but those resistors were readily available.

   One side note about the Hobo U12-4 is that it forces all the grounds to be the same for all the four data channels it is acquiring data from.  This was a bit of a problem for my application.  I intended to record 1) the solar PV voltage, 2) the battery voltage, and 3) the load voltage.  Unfortunately that did not work with this system as forcing the grounds to be the same for those three items made the charge controller malfunction.  So, for my data collecting, I settled on only collecting the load voltage.


On the worst day
After recording data for several days, a pattern emerged.  On the worst days the load voltage looked like the following graph.
In the early morning hours, the voltage was switched off because it was below the 21 volt minimum.  In fact, the voltage was probably below 10 volts.  The pack was well and truly drained.  Starting about 7:00 in the morning, light began to fall on the panels.  Unfortunately, the battery voltage was so low, the charge controller tries to put the system into 12 volt mode which makes it impossible for the valves to open because they require 24 volts.
   The charge controller repeatedly turns the voltage on and off as the battery voltage fluctuates as the differential controller starts to turn on and draw loads.  This continues until about 11:00 when enough solar flux lands on the solar panels and somehow the charge controller decides that this is a 24 volt battery pack after all.
    Throughout the day, 27.5 volts is applied to the battery pack to charge it, perhaps ending at 5:00 pm.  From that time on, the differential controller draws about 1.5 watts from the pack which result in the battery voltage dropping slowly.  Around approximately 8:00 at night, it looks like one of the cells suddenly drops voltage significantly.  Later, at approximately 9:00 at night, another cell voltage collapses and the voltage drops below 21 Volts.
    From that point on, there is repeated cycling.  When the voltage drops below 21 volts, the charge controller cuts the power to the load.  With the load removed, the battery voltage recovers a little and once above 23 volts, the charge controller restores the voltage to the load.  This quickly drops the battery voltage back below 21 volts and the load is cutoff from the batteries, and the cycle continues.


On the most days
Most days didn't see the charge controller automatically switch to 12 volt mode as can be seen in the graph below.

 But in every other regard, the behavior is similar with a difficult cyclical startup in the morning and a cyclical end to the day.

 
So what is the problem
  One of the more troubling aspects of the data is that only 27.5 volts is applied to the pack during the day.  This amounts to (27.5V/20cells) = 1.38 volts per cell.  This should be enough to charge the batteries, but I have seen my smart charger apply 1.4V or more to these cells to properly charge them.  So perhaps a little more voltage per cell would be useful.

   However, there isn't any charging voltage adjustment on the low priced charge controller that I'm using.  An alternative is to use fewer batteries.
    Given how the battery pack is constructed, it would be useful to have a "dummy" battery that is just a shorted cell.  Fortunately I found some on ebay and purchased them as shown in the picture below.

So what is the solution
I decided to try 19 eneloop batteries and one dummy battery.  That would give (27.5V/19cell=) 1.45 volts/cell, which is significantly more than the 1.38 volts/cell previously available.  The results were immediate and dramatic.

After a day to let the batteries charge, for the first time, the battery pack was able to run the differential controller all night long and into the next day as can be seen in the graph.  The battery voltage never dipped down below 24 volts which is well above the 21 volt cutoff for the charge controller.  The difficult startup seen most mornings, with the cyclical behavior, was eliminated and it looks like the valves opened cleanly on the first time (although that behavior was not recorded).

Into the future
The only remaining question is can the batteries be maintained over, say, a week of cloudy days and then startup smoothly when the sun returns.  One possible solution to that problem would be a PV panel cut-off.  This would be a circuit that would cut power to the load unless the sun is shining brightly on the solar PV panels and producing at least some voltage (e.g. 24 volt).  This would prevent the drain on the battery in the evening and could make it possible for the battery pack to stay charged almost indefinitely.

Update:  Sure enough, after a couple of back to back cloudy days, the batteries were exhausted and power to the differential controller was cut by the charge controller.



 

Sunday, July 21, 2013

Solar Hot Water Performance Measurement Part 2

   With almost two years worth of data from the solar hot water system, now might be a good time to review how well it is working.

   The solar hot water system is run in series with a traditional oil furnace so that the better the solar system works, the less oil is consumed.  For nearly three years now, the run time of the furnace has been measured, a time span that includes one year before the installation of the solar hot water system and two years since its installation.
  
    The furnace is monitored using a Hobo U9-004 motor on/off data logger.  The logger comes with a magnetic back that allows it to be attached to the furnace fuel pump motor.  A sensor inside the logger detects the varying magnetic fields that leak from the AC motor when it is running and creates a log entry every time the motor turns on or off.  This data has to be processed with an Excel spreadsheet to compute "duty cycle", i.e. what fraction of the time the motor is on during the day.

    One last trick for this measurement is the knowing that the burner nozzle dispenses oil at a fixed rate.  Conveniently, my burner nozzle outputs 1 gallon per hour.  So if my furnace runs for 1 hour per day or a 4% duty cycle (1/24), then 1 gallon of fuel will be consumed per day.  At about $4/gallon, that would work out to about $4/day.  So on to the data.


 The graph above shows a full year's worth of data (365 data points) from the 2010 to 2011 heating season.  There are a few things worthy of note. First is that during the heating season, there is a lot of day to day variation in the percentage of time that the furnace has to run in response to day to day changes in weather.  In contrast, the fuel consumption in the summer is more consistent as it only varies with the amount of hot water used and idle losses in the furnace.

   The discussion of the oil consumption is facilitated by constructing a simplified model of the furnace usage and fitting curves based on that model.  The first assumption is that there are two seasons for a furnace, Winter and Summer.  During the winter, the furnace usage depends on 1) home heating load, 2) hot water usage, and 3) idle losses.  During the summer, the furnace usage only depends on the last two of these items.  The next assumption is that the winter usage can be represented by a simple parabolic curve fit and the summer by a constant value.  These lines are shown on the graph.


 The graph above shows three years worth of data, and the impact of the solar hot water heater can easily be seen by comparing the summers.  The summers of 2012 and 2013 show far lower furnace duty cycle  than in 2011.   Ideally, the consumption would be zero in the summer, but unfortunately, the way the furnace controls are set up, the furnace works to keep itself at 140°F all year long whether it needs to be on or not.  This might be fixable in the future with a "furnace bypass" system.

   Also note in the graph that there is significant variation during the winter from one year to the next.  This is most likely due to the intensity of the winter weather varying significantly from one year to the next.   The impact of the solar hot water system in the winter is likely to be small (due to less sun) and difficult to measure due to the fact that most of furnace run time is going into heating the home.



   The graph above shows the same data with a different vertical scale (gallons of oil consumed per day).  In the summer of 2011, about 1.13 gallons/day is consumed.  However, in the summer of 2012, only about 0.47 gallons per day are consumed due to the addition of the solar hot water system.  Over the roughly 150 days of the summer, this resulted in 177 gallons consumed in 2011 versus 71 gallons in 2012.

    This amounts to approximately 100 gallons of oil saved in the summer alone.  At $4/gallon, this means there is about a $400/year savings just based on the summer data.  Now given the over $8000 out-of-pocket expenses I have laid out for the solar hot water system, it might take a long time to break-even on my investment.  But there are a couple of bright spots.  Firstly, there is likely some additional savings in the winter.  Secondly, I should be able to put a furnace-bypass system in place now to further reduce oil consumption in the summer.  Thirdly, it seems likely that oil prices will rise in the future and that would reduce payback time still more.

   The relatively small financial saving here are sobering.  However, solar power systems are too cool to be judged solely on the dollars.  There is great personal satisfaction from heating your home water using the only the sunlight that falls on your property versus from oil being pumped up out of the ground in the middle east and shipped halfway around the world and then burned in your furnace creating local pollution.





Sunday, July 14, 2013

Measuring Performance of the Solar Hot Water System

    "So how is your solar hot water heater working out for you?" I am often asked.  This simple question often has me struggling for a simple answer.   For my solar electric panels, I can tell people that the panels make more electricity in the summer than I use and I get a ZERO dollar electric bill about six months of the year.  This seems to satisfy most people.  So why can't I say something similar about my solar hot water panels?  In one word, it's instrumentation.
   Solar electric panels typical record the number of KiloWatt Hours (KWH) produced either daily, weekly, or cumulatively (most likely all of the above).  Solar hot water panels, in contrast, record absolutely nothing.  The differential temperature controller turns the pump on and off as needed, but does not record anything.
     It is technically possible to record the amount of energy produced by the solar hot water panels.  Caleffi makes the WMZ-G1 Energy Heat Meter (257202A $250).  But to use it, you must also buy the Vortex Flow Sensor (NA15015 $117) and the Relative Pressure Sensor (NA15014 $90), both of which also measure temperature.  And if you want the data stored, you must also get the DL2 data logger (257201A $410).   All of which ends up being about $1000 after getting all the fittings to plumb it into your system.  As an Engineer, I love data, but adding $1000 to the price of my system just to get data, seems a little steep.

   Having forgone the expensive option during installation, I put a simple data logger on my 2012 Christmas wish list which my loving wife picked up for me (nothing says you care more than a data logger for Christmas).  This beauty was an Onset Computing Hobo U12-006 four channel 12-bit recorder ($113) capable of recording 43,000 data points all while being powered with a single CR2032 watch battery which lasts more than one year.  Complementing the data logger was a TMC6-HD temperature sensor ($39) which was installed in the bottom of the 80 gallon hot water tank.

Unfortunately, the data logger cannot record the amount of energy produced, but it can give some very useful insight into the performance of the solar hot water system.  At this point in time, I have a full year and a half worth of data recorded that can give some graphical feedback on the performance of the system.

A Day In The Life

   The graph below shows a typical 24 hour cycle for the solar hot water system.  Starting at midnight, the bottom of the tank is at 92.7°F showing that there is very little heat left in the tank, although the top of the tank is probably considerably hotter and that is what really counts.
   By around 7 am, the temperature has slowly dropped to 91.0°F due to a small loss of heat from the well insulated stainless steel tank.  Then someone wakes up to take a shower.
    By 7:30 am the temperature in the tank has dropped to 86.0°F as a result of the shower.  Most likely, the hot water from the tank was not hot enough for a shower, and some supplemental heating via the oil furnace was needed.  Nevertheless, the water was at least partially heated by the sun.
    Then the sun gets down to business.  Between 9 am and 3 pm, the 80 gallon tank is heated to 158.8°F.  This is pretty impressive with water more than hot enough for a shower.  Over the course of the afternoon, the temperature of the tank drops to 147°F likely due to some incidental use of water (hand washing, dishwasher, clothes washer, etc) and heat traveling up to the top of the water tank leaving the colder water at the bottom.
   From about 7pm to 9pm, the water temperature drifts slowly downward from 147 to 145.3°F likely due to losses through the insulated tank walls or conduction out through the connected copper pipes.
    At about 9:30pm a second family member takes a shower dropping the temperature at the bottom of the tank from 145.3 to 128.7°F.
    Starting at midnight, the cycle will repeat itself the next day in the same way, as long as the sun is shining.



A Year and a Half In The Life

 The graph below shows about 70,000 data points for the temperature at the bottom of the tank.  Remember from the graph above, that each day the tank cycles from cold to hot to cold again as the water is heated up and then used in showers.  So within a one day cycle it is possible for the measurement to be as low as 60°F and as high as 180°F (which is the maximum setting before the heat is sent to the heat dump).
    Concentrate of the lower part of the graph for a moment.  The horizontal axis starts at January 2012, passes through a full year to January 2013 and on for an additional half year until July 2013.  It is clear that in the winter, the incoming water temperature is about 50°F.  In the spring and the fall, the incoming water temperature increases to about 60°F.  In the middle of the summer of 2013, the temperature seldom falls below 80°F.  However, it would seem unlike that the incoming water temperature is so high.  Instead, the more likely explanation is that not all of the 80 gallons of hot water in the tank is needed in the summer and some residual heat is left in the tank on most summer days.
      Now concentrate of the upper part of the graph.  In January, the water is only heated up to about 75°F by the sun.  If you are a glass is half empty sort of person, it would seem that the solar hot water system is "doing nothing".  But in fact, the water is being slightly "pre-heated" before the fossil fuel furnace has to heat it the rest of the way to 140°F.  So some solar heating is better than none.  
     Starting some time in March or April, more serious water heating begins with temperatures pushing to the 140 to 150°F range.  Also notice that sometimes the sun does not shine for several days and the water temperature remains at 60°F.
    In the middle of the summer, the peak temperatures for the day are often above 170°F supplying ample hot water for showers.


    While this data is interesting, it really doesn't supply a quick answer to the question of "how is your solar hot water system working?"  But at least it shows that the systems is working, and, in the summers at least, working quite well.




Friday, January 11, 2013

To Float, or Not To Float, that is the question for the Hydrometer

As it is now the middle of the winter, and getting very cold, concern naturally arises about the quality of the anti-freeze in the solar hot water system.  It has been over a year in service and the hot summer temperatures might have degraded the anti-freeze properties of the propylene glycol/water mixture.  If cold temperature outside causes the solar working fluid to freeze, it will ruin some very expensive solar panels.

The tool for checking out the quality of the anti-freeze is called a hydrometer.  This uses the specific gravity of the working fluid as an indicator of the level of freeze protection.

The most common hydrometers are used for testing the anti-freeze in car radiators.  However, those hydrometers will not work for the solar panels.  Cars use highly toxic ethylene glycol which has a different specific gravity than the non-toxic propylene glycol used in the solar panels.  The hydrometer must say on it that it is for propylene glycol or the reading will be wrong.

As a good starting point for any shopping these days, I surfed on over to Amazon.com.  There I found the Thexton 107 Cold-Chek for about $15 with mostly 5 star reviews.
 The basic working principle is easy enough, suck up some fluid into the device and see how many disks float.  If one disk floats, the fluid is good to +20°F, if all five disks floats, the fluid is good to -50°F.  To get started, I tried some water as shown on the left side of the picture below.  As expected, none of the disks floated indicating no freeze protection at all.
 
Next I removed a small amount of solar working fluid from the fill/drain port on the solar hot water system.  As can be seen on the right side of the image above, all the disks float and I should be good to -50°F which is very reassuring .

I will try to remember to come back and check this again next year.

One slight problem with the hydrometer was that it was easy to get false readings.  Air bubbles can attach themselves to the disks and cause them to float.  This made my measurements on the water totally unreliable.  After playing with it for a while, I discovered the vigorously tapping the side of the plastic housing caused the air bubbles to rise and then the disks would give a true reading.  I learned that a disk floating may be an error, but if you get it to sink, that is the correct reading.

Next post, I will talk about my worryingly low pressure in the solar working fluid.

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

The tax man cometh... and brings gifts

    Yes it is that time of the year again, yet some of us are looking forward to it for a change.  Tax season.

  Agree or disagree, the federal government is willing to pay for 30% of the installed cost of solar hot water systems.  And if the government is offering, then surely I am going to take them up on it.



  Having spent just shy of $12,500 (I know it is a lot!) on my hot water system, the government has sent me a check for $3,750.  Not too bad.  That leaves me $8,750 out of pocket for the system.  We will see, in the months and years ahead, whether that was a good or bad investment.  However, considering (a) I heat with oil and (b) I lived through the 1974 OPEC oil embargo, I think the peace of mind will be well worth it.

   Next up, more 2" thick foam insulation for my basement walls to save even more oil.

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

How Much is 80 Gallons of Hot Water Worth?

Winter is finally giving way to spring, and the sun is now clearing more of the trees that have been shading the solar panels.  The result is that for two straight days in a row, the system has produced 80 gallons of 160 F water.  That leads me to this question, how much is that really worth.  Time to break out Excel.


So the water starts out (at this time of year) at 52 F and is heated to 160 F, for a delta T of 108 F.  The 80 gallons of water weighs 668 lbs and given that a BTU is the energy needed to raise 1 pound of water by 1 degree, this totals 668*108=72,144 BTU.    But what does that really mean?

If that water had not been heated by the sun, it would need to be heated by home heating oil burning in the furnace.  Let's assume that the furnace is only 80% efficient, so in stead of 72,144 BTU, we would need 90,126 BTU from the fuel.  Looking up on the internet, we see that there is 139,000 BTU in one gallon of home heating oil.  Thus we saved 0.65 gallons/day or (at $4/gallon) $2.59/day.

Well that hardly seems worth the thousands of dollars that I spent on the solar hot water system.  But before we conclude that, let's look at how much this adds up to over the course of the year.

Let's assume that half the time, the system will produce a tank full of hot water.  That is 182.5 days per year.  So, I will save 118 gallons/year or $473/year. 

At that rate, it will take a depressing 17 years to pay back the $8000 of out of pocket expenses (after federal 30% tax credit.)  However, there are two more things to consider.  First, it may be possible for me to shut off the furnace during the summer which might double the savings.  Second, perhaps over the next 10 or 20 years, oil might cost a lot more than $4/gallon, accelerating the payback.  That may make facing the future just a little bit more bearable.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

Solar PV Panel on the move

Rather than make the sensible choice and plug my solar differential controller and pump into the "mains" AC power, I chose to use a solar PV (photovoltaic) panel to supply this electricity.  This choice continues to cause issues.

The latest issue is that sometimes I find that the Taco zone valves fail to open and the solar hot water system overheats because the pump cannot pump the fluid past a closed valve.  The problem with the Taco zone valve is not clear.  I have tried to duplicate the problem by turning on and off a power supply connected to a spare zone valve.  The valve seems to work flawlessly.

On the actual solar hot water system, however, on a few occasions, I have seen the valve fail to open.  The problem is that the power available to open the valve is inadequate in the morning.  This causes continuous cycling and resetting of the solar controller and the valve.  When the solar fluid gets hot enough, the solar controller attempts to turn on the valve and the pump.  This causes too much load on the batteries and PV panel and the 24 VDC power drops below the cutout voltage of the controller (about 22 volts) and the controller shuts off and the valve closes.  With this load removed, the battery voltage quickly recovers to 24 VDC and the system turns on, only to repeat the same reset cycle.

The problem seems to be largely caused by my chosen location for the solar PV panel which is on the right of the Heliodyne solar hot water panels.  In this location, the solar PV panel is getting shade in the morning even when the hot water panels are in the sun.  The result is that there is inadequate electrical current to turn the system on when needed in the morning.  Usually this just means that the system continues to cycle and reset for 10 or 15 minutes until adequate PV power is available.  This would be no big deal.  However, the weakness in the zone valve means that under some combination of reset cycling, the valve ends up closed for the whole day.  That is bad.

To work around this problem, I have decided to relocate the PV panel to a location with less shading.  Specifically, I decided to put the panel at the top center of the hot water panels.  The picture below shows the old PV panel location.
And the next picture shows the new location.
Initially, I had rejected that location for the PV panel because I didn't want it to block the view from the window.  However, I think it looks fine at that location and the symmetry looks nice.

To hold the panel in place, I used about $100 worth of aluminum extrusions and other part from Misumi.  The aluminum extrusions are HFS8-4040 from Misumi which is 40x40 millimeters or about 1.5 inch square.  These are coupled into the Misumi frame that I used to hold up the solar hot water panels.  All the fasteners are stainless steel so the frame and fasteners should not rust.

As typical, I laid this all out in Pro/Engineer before hand to make sure everything would fit.
The first sunny day showed that this location works much better and the controller was able to turn on the valve and pump with no problem early in the morning.  Ultimately, the choice of solar PV based electricity over mains power may ultimately prove to be the right one.

Saturday, January 21, 2012

Battery Pack Woes

My battery pack and I are having relationship problems.  I think it should work every day, but it thinks it deserves a day off once in a while.  So I have fired it from its job.  Let me back up for a moment.

The solar hot water system needs a small amount of electricity to run the pump, valves, and controller.  You can get this electricity from the wall outlet, but I decided to get it from a separate 40 watt photovoltaic solar panel.  But if the sun ever ducks behind a cloud, even for a moment, that power is lost, valves start closing... and repeated cloud passing can make the system cycle on and off repeatedly.  So to stabilize the system I am using a charge controller and a battery.

Charge controllers mix together electricity from the solar panel and the battery to optimize the power output.  If excess power is available, the system charges the battery.  If solar output drops, the power can be supplied from the battery, at least for a short while, and prevent valves from closing.

Charge controllers are built assuming that you are going to use either one 12 volt lead acid battery or two together (24 volts).  I have no interest in using lead acid batteries because they only last about 3 years.  So I decided to make my own 24 volt battery from AA Sanyo Eneloop NiMH batteries.

The first challenge was how many batteries did I need to mimic the 24 volts that the charge controller is expecting.  Each NiMH cell is about 1.25 volts so twenty batteries would produce a theoretical 25 volts.  This seems close enough.

Next challenge is to find a battery holder for 20 AA cells.  Since I could not find one,  I decided to put together three holders, two 8 cell (2×4) and one 4 cell (2×2).  The photo below shows what I came up with.



At the top of the battery holder is three 9V style connectors that I had to connect together to get the total 24V output.  To hold this assembly together, I bent some sheet metal and glued it to the outside.  Of course I needed to be careful that the metal did not short out any of the electrical contacts.

The Problem

Shortly after installing the system I started noticing problems with the battery.  Sometimes when I touched the battery holder, the voltage would drop to zero.  After some fiddling, the voltage would be back to normal with no clear reason way.  Other times, I would find the battery pack completely dead with the cells reading 0V each.  Upon removing the batteries from the pack they would slowly recover to about 1V suggesting they were being loaded in the pack.  I am not sure why these problems were happening, but decided a new, cleaner, battery holder might help.


I found batteries holders on the web that could hold 10 cells, so I only needed two of them rather than three holder used in the last system.  By placing them back to back, I would make one nice twenty cell holder.  I just needed to solder two terminals at the top, solder some leads, and tape the outer edges with electrical tape.



The new battery holder is installed and working well. 

I have had a discussion with my new battery pack and it has agreed to work every day and not just occasionally.  Hope springs eternal and I believe it. (for now).

Monday, January 2, 2012

Plumber makes final connection, Impressed me, not so much

Generally I am a fan of building codes that keep the public safe.  It is great that only qualified people do things like install foundations, chimneys, high voltage lines, etc.  So I was not that disappointed when I learned that I had to hire a professional plumber to make the final potable water connections for solar hot water system.

I have changed my opinion.

The idea sounds great in practice, but the execution is not always a guaranteed success.  Let me share with you my experience with the plumber.

Firstly, the task was very simple.  Break open the feed to the existing fossil fuel hot water heater, route it to the solar hot water tank, then route it back.  The idea is that the solar hot water system acts as a preheat for the existing furnace based tankless heater.

My preferred plumber (Plumber 1) wanted $1100 to do the job.  This is impressively expensive for a couple of hours of work.  I tried to hire him, but he stopped returning my phone calls due to many "no-heat" calls from a freak fall snow storm that knocked out power to many homes in the area (including mine for 28 hours).  After a while, I called on Plumber 2 that only wanted $700 to do the job, fine, I hired him.  By the time it was done, he charged me $1000 for a crappy job, but I paid him anyway.  I really should have waited from Plumber 1 due to past good experience with him.

The best thing that can be said is that the system "worked" after the plumber left and the job site was left very clean.  Unfortunately, the quality of the work could have been much better.  Let me enumerate the ways that the plumber "failed" (in my humble opinion).

FAIL 1: The Backflow Preventer
The plumbing inspector required the plumber to install a backflow preventer for some unknown reason.  Perhaps there was concern that the non-toxic propylene glycol might work itself back to the street under some impossible scenario.  Of course, that would not help us here in the house.  If the propylene glycol leaks, it will come right in to the hot water supply and we will likely drink it.  That is not much of a problem since it is non-toxic, so I don't know why a backflow preventer was needed.  Also, if this had been a fossil-fuel fired heater, no backflow preventer would have been required.  This is clearly a case of fear of the unknown, but shouldn't have been a big deal, if it was installed correctly.
  The backflow preventer should have been installed for the whole house water supply, however it was installed just in the hot water feeder line.  The resulting back-pressure made the hot water supply pressure very low while leaving the cold water supply pressure high.  The result was that it was impossible properly adjust the temperature of the shower without micron precision on the hot and cold water taps. 
So I removed the backflow preventer and installed a short length of pipe instead.
Upon removing the backflow preventer, it became clear that it was plugged with plumbing putty or some such material as can be seen in the image.  It was almost completely plugged.  What kind of plumber does such lousy work?  I thought this might have flushed out of the new hot water tank and then perhaps be the fault of the tank manufacturer.  However the backflow preventer is before the hot water tank.  So this material must have come from the plumbers new work.
FAIL 2: Can't close 1/4 valve.
If there is a 1/4 turn ball valve in the existing plumbing, you would think the plumber would know not to run pipes in such a way that the valve cannot be closed.  As can be seen in the image, the yellow handled full port ball valve cannot completely close because it now hits a pipe.  Nice work.
FAIL 3: Tempering valve defeated
If you are not a plumber, you might not have heard of a tempering valve.  This is an important piece of safety equipment in your home.  If you have a furnace (or boiler) then it is possible that it could malfunction and produce seriously hot water, e.g. 210F.  If this came up your pipes into your shower you might be badly scalded.
   To prevent this, a tempering valve is installed.  The tempering valve takes in both hot and cold water, as shown in the picture.  If the hot water is above a certain temperature, the tempering valve mixes in a small amount of cold water to reduce, or temper, the water temperature so you are not scalded.
However, my plumber managed to connect hot water to both sides of the tempering valve making is dangerously useless.  He plumbed the solar hot water into the cold port of the valve, and furnace hot water into the hot port of the valve.  The result is that the tempering valve cannot function as intended.  This is probably due to the plumber's lack of familiarity with solar hot water systems.  Alternatively, perhaps I should had developed a plumbing diagram and given it to the plumber.  That seems a little silly for someone that is supposed to know how to do this, but there you have it.
This is really a double fail because the inspector didn't catch this error either.

FAIL 4: No Unions or 1/4 turn shut off valves
This might be a bit of a nitpick, but here goes.  As recommended by the manufacturer of the hot water tank, I installed unions and 1/4 ball valves  just above the hot water tank on the solar loop.  This allows the tank to be disconnected if service is needed.
However, the plumber defeated my efforts by not installing them on the potable water side of the tank.
So if service is needed on the tank, I will need to cut the copper lines on the potable water side.

Fail 5: Pretzel Plumbing
There is a certain art to plumbing.  A well done job not only works, but it looks neat and clean.  The plumber only had to run two lines and inexplicably he didn't run them along the same path.
As can be seen in the image, the cold line (blue) and the hot line (red) are not run along the same path even though they easily could have.  This would also have avoided the cold line running into the 1/4 turn shutoff valve.


All in all, the whole job was pretty disappointing and only barely functional.  The work was neat and clean, but the plumber failed in the five ways shown above.  He also seemed quite uncertain about whether or not an expansion tank was needed and ultimately installed one even though he worked to try to convince me that a tank was not needed.  All this difficulty occurred despite A) hiring a pleasant experienced plumber and B) getting a personal recommendation to hire this plumber.

I guess tradesman, in general, are not big thinkers.  They do what their fathers and grandfathers have always done, no matter if it is good or bad, unless it totally and utterly fails to work or the law requires something new to be done.

Wish I had done the plumbing myself and ultimately will probably remove all of it and install my own plumbing correctly.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

The Bill Comes Due

You know the feeling don't you?  You open up, say, the credit card bill at month's end and you think, all those little numbers cannot possibly add up to that BIG number at the bottom of the bill.  Unfortunately, all those little numbers do add up.  And so it is true with my solar hot water project.

Jumping to the bottom, the number is $12,000, give or take a little depending on what you include.  And, yes, that is a lot.  But I was not trying to do a budget job, and mistakes along the way cost mucho dinaro.  Still, assuming the federal government pays for 30% that leaves only $8400 for me to make up with oil savings and still seems possible within a few years.  More feedback on that later.

There are a handful of big ticket items and about one hundred smaller purchases.  To begin, let's talk about the larger items or main components which total $6353.12.


System Vendor Date Description Price
1 Solar Panels EcoDirect.com 08/04/11 Solar Panels $2,829.85
2 Tank Houseneeds 09/25/11 Hot water tank $1,825.08
3 Hydronics Houseneeds 08/09/11 Pump Station, fittings $557.83
4 Hydronics Portland Group 04/12/11 NA26711 Caleffi pump $363.63
5 Controller House Needs 03/29/11 iSolar Plus Controller $333.75
6 Hydronics SunVolt Energy 11/03/11 Ecocirc Pump $189.25
7 Solar PV Amazon 10/10/11 two 20 W Solar Panels $156.48
8 Hydronics Houseneeds 08/25/11 Fittings for pump station $97.25

The largest most expensive purchase, by far, is the panels at about $3000.  The good news is that EcoDirect has very reasonable shipping at $130.  The same shipping from AltE would have been over $1000.  It is also worth noting that the price would have been a lot lower if I could have used two 4×10' panels rather than three 4×6'.

The second most expensive item is the solar hot water tank.  At about $1800, the price might be more than a little surprising to anyone that has purchased an electric hot water tank for, say, $400.  But there are two things to keep in mind.  First, this tank has a heat exchanger inside so I didn't need to configure an external heat exchanger and a second pump.  Second, this is a stainless steel tank that should last more than twice as long as a standard steel tank.  At least that is what I am hoping and the lifetime warranty makes me believe.

Items 3,4,5, and 8 basically make up all of the Califfi Solar Pump station including the pump, controller and fittings.  This is a whopping $1,352 which seems like an awful lot for what it does.  The Caleffi equipment is nice, but it seems grossly overpriced.  Caleffi does nicely put all the little plumbing components (check valve, pump, temperature gauges, pressure gauge, air bleeder, fill ports, controller) all into one nice little package.  But the price will make the budget conscious person think about making there own system instead of buying from Caleffi.

Item 6 is me having to buy the pump a second time because the Caleffi pump really isn't the right one for the job.  I have listed the old pump on ebay and Amazon and hope to recover some of the money

Item 7 is the solar panels, which were also purchased twice for this job.  First I bought two 10 watt panels and then discovered that they were too small, then I bought two 20 watt panels.  Also, my insistence on using solar electric power contributed greatly to the cost of this system.  In addition to the cost of the PV panels, the pump is more expensive and the controls and electronics are more complex.   It is no wonder that AC power is used for most of these systems.

All-in-All, these main components represent only 50% of the total system cost.  The "balance of system" or other parts cost just is much which is shocking.  I will cover those costs in a separate post.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Laing Eco-circ pump

   It was probably too much to expect everything to work perfectly and it hasn't.

   When the Laing Eco-circ pump turns, it is designed to use as much electric power as possible from the solar panels (PV).  Unfortunately that causes the system voltage level to drop to 17 volts and the battery charge controller stops working and eventually the controller would shut down due to lack of power.  A secondary problem is that the pump is circulating the water too fast.  It is pumping well in excess of 5 gpm (gallon per minute) which is much faster that the 2.5 gpm that is recommended by Heliodyne for the solar panels.  Too much gpm and using too much electricity.

    So I contacted Laing technical support (which appears to be Xylem Inc part of ITT) and got some great help from Amy Flores.  Long story short, it looks like Caleffi made a mistake by using the D5 "strong" pump.  That pump is really intended more for maximizing flow of fluid which is not what you want in solar hot water panels.  It is probably great for well water pumping, but not for solar hot water panels where flow control is needed.

   Fortunately Laing makes an Eco-circ D5 "Vario" pump which has, as the name suggests, variable flow settings.  There is a dial on the side of the pump where you can adjust the volumetric flow.  The image shows the two different pump types.  On the left is the "strong" pump that pumps the water as fast as possible.  The pump on the right is the "vario" version with a small red dial that allows the flow to be adjusted and save some electric power as well.
 The design of the eco-circ is really excellent.  The pump/impeller side can be easily separated from the involute/pipe fitting side.  This allowed me (really Amy gets credit for this idea) take the new motor and attach it to the Caleffi fittings (which are custom).  So I took half of one eco-circ and screwed it to the other half of a second eco-circ pump to get what I needed.  The "vario" pump was purchased from Sun Volt Energy (www.sunvoltenergy.net) for $179 which is an excellent price considering I paid $325 for the Caleffi pump.  Sun Volt got the pump out to me in just a couple of days which was great.  The image shows the two halves of the pump.
 As can be seen in the picture, the official part number for the "Vario" is D-38/710B.  I found the Eco-circ part numbers to be confusing.
  The Results:  This is the best part.  Using the dial, I could adjust the speed of the motor until I had 2.5 gpm flow as shown in the picture.  I give Caleffi credit for including this nice flowmeter into their pumping station design.  Without the flowmeter, I would have no idea what kind of flow I was getting.
   Now for the best part, connecting the pump to a power supply and the power supply to a Kill-a-watt, I found that the power used is only 9 watts versus the 50 watts used by the old eco-circ pump.  Can't wait to see if it works as well on sun-light power.  Think about it for a minute. 2.5 gpm for 9 watts!  Many home circulators require more than ten times the power to do the same job.  Well done Laing.
   The hot water tank still needs to be connected to the domestic hot water system.  Hope to do that soon.  A plumber is coming tomorrow to look at the system and another plumber said he would do it for $1100.  I would prefer to do this myself, but officially, only a licensed plumber is supposed to do the job.  The whole project has turned out to be way too expensive.  However, I must complete the project at this point to be done with it and get the benefits.

Sunday, October 16, 2011

Furnance Duty Cycle

   The primary motivation for putting in the solar panels has been to reduce oil consumption and the ultimate success or failure will be judged by the oil savings.

    But measuring oil consumption is slightly difficult and very low resolution.  The truck comes to your house and fills the tank about 8 times per year. It is difficult to know how much oil is used in any given month and you can forget about seeing any consumption data on a daily basis in a way that is easily possible for metered products like electricity.

   However, I have found another way to measure oil consumption.  The technique has two parts.  First, the furnace supposedly uses 1.0 gallon per minute when it is on.  Secondly, there are data recorders (data loggers) that can measure when a motor is on.

   The data logger that I used is called a HOBO from manufactured by a company called Onset.  This is a great product.  You can log one year's worth of data.  It only uses one CR2032 watch battery, attaches to the motor with a magnet, and remotely senses the motor state based on fluctuating magnetic fields.  It has a USB port and the data can be downloaded to the HOBO software.  It is about $100 for the data logger and another $100 for the software. 
  What was a slight pain was parsing the data in Excel.  What I really want to know is Duty Cycle, or the percentage of time that the furnace is on in a given day.  What I start with is a bunch of time events that indicate when the motor turned on or off.  I spent a few hours writing a VBA macro in Excel to parse the data the way I wanted.  The biggest problem is splitting events that happen just before or just after midnight.  But the result is just what I wanted.


The chart is a little complicated so let me walk you through it.  On the horizontal axis is time, about one year starting at the beginning of heating season around October 7.  The black dots are data points for the duty cycle.  If the duty cycle was 50% it means that the furnace was firing half of the time.  I have almost a full year's worth of data.
   Since the data is a little noisy, I fit it with two curves.  One curve is parabolic and represent the heating season.  The second curve is linear and represents the summer season.  This gives a clearer representation of the two uses of the furnace 1) domestic heat, and 2) domestic hot water.  It seems reasonable to assume that the domestic hot water is fairly consistent throughout the year.  In fact, it looks like there is a baseline usage of about 5% or roughly 1 gallon of oil every day.
    The oil usage might rightly be broken down into three usage
1) Domestic home heating
2) Domestic hot water
3) Idle losses
Even if no one was in the house and it was summer, my furnace would still consume oil due to the old fashion "tankless" water heater.  The tankless heater requires the furnace to maintain temperature 24/7/365 just in case someone wants some hot water.

    It is difficult to separate hot water usage from idle losses so I have grouped them together in one group in the graph.  Hot water and idle losses represent about 40% of the oil consumed or 377gallons.  Of that, probably half is hot water and half is idling losses.  So a big win for the solar hot water system will be for it to make enough hot water to allow me to shut off the furnace in the summer.  If oil is $4/gallon, then 377 gallons/year means $1508/year, but I will never achieve that much savings because it is not sunny every day and I am not sure how to automatically shut the furnace off and I might also need to bypass the furnace to get this system to work, something I have yet to figure out how to do. Step-by-Step.

  For domestic heating, an estimated 555 gallons (60%) are used per year.  So perhaps I should have spent my money on a more efficient furnace rather than solar water heater system.  But then again, perhaps I can do the furnace upgrade in the future.

  The estimate shows about 932 gallons/year total oil consumption.  This number is quite good because in the 2009-2010 season I used 942 gallons, so the estimate might be within +/-5%.  The insight gained from the data logger information more than makes up for the possible +/-5% error.

   Hopefully in a year, we will have lower duty cycle numbers to share with you.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Up and Circulating

Once all the plumbing was in place, I was more than a little nervous about whether or not the system would hold pressure.  One bad solder joint could make my life very difficult.  So I set about the process of filling the system.

In order to fill the system, I purchased a 1/2 hp "jet pump" that is used for wells.  The pump would be used to draw water (or propylene glycol) from a bucket and pump it into the system.  Of course, like everything else, this meant taking a trip to Home Depot to figure out the appropriate fittings.  The inlet of the pump was a massive 1 1/4" NPT thread but the outlet was only a 3/4" NPT thread.  These would need to be adapted to "hose bib" fittings.    I found a 1 1/4" to 3/4" adapter so that the inlet and outlet were now both the same and I also found two 3/4" npt to 3/4" hose bib adapters.  Also purchased a couple of washing machine hookup hoses to connect the pump in to the solar pumping station.
  The water could then be pumped out of the orange buckets and into the system.  The fluid was then returned back to the bucket in one continuous loop.

     Unfortunately, I had two leaks. SIGH.  The first leak was between two of the solar panels.  It looks like I was not careful enough when installing the panels and one of the o-rings got pinched between the brass surfaces.  The o-ring was damaged and had to be replaced.  The second leak was one of the copper unions that I had placed above the hot water tank to facilitate service.  This union had a large open pore (void) in the surface where sealing was to occur (Thanks Cello).  So I purchased a new union from Home Depot for $17 rather than the $9 I had spent on-line for the other ones, but anyway it was replaced.
    Now to deal with the broken O-ring.  After having spent more than $3000 with Heliodyne, you might think they would have included a spare O-ring, but no.  Strike 1.  But should be simple enough to find a replacemtn.  It is a 1.250×3/32" o-ring.  So I go to Home Depot, Strike 2, they only have o-rings for kitchen faucets.   Go into work where there is a huge selection of o-rings.  There is a 1.250×1/8" but no 3/32".  Strike 3.  Drive to Sears Hardware in Ashland because I knew the Sears Hardware in Delaware (near where I formerly worked) had drawers full of o-rings.  But Sears Hardware Ashland doesn't have o-ring drawers.  Strike 4, but the Sears salesman does give me a tip to look at Ace hardware (which was closed at the time).  On the way home, I went to Lowes which also does not have o-rings despite the Lowes salesmen sending me on a wild goose chase. Strike 5 with four hours wasted.  The next day, I went to Lexington Ace Hardware near my house and purchased the needed o-ring for 59 cents.  Sigh.

   With the leaks fixed, I charged the system with water and it held.  Then I flushed the system with a water and TSP (tri-sodium phosphate) cleaner for several hours.   Next I flushed TSP out of the system with 20 gallons of clean water.  The jet pump moves the fluid at more than 5 gallons per minute.  Very impressive to see a 5 gallon bucket emptied that quickly.

   One small problem is that the flowmeter on the pumping station stopped working some time during this process.  The flushing had liberated some steel (or aluminum but not copper) shavings that got caught up in the flowmeter.  That required removing the flowmeter and removing the metal with tweezers.  Put the flowmeter back in and things were up an running.

Circulating on its own.

  It is all very well and good to use the charge pump, but the system should function with its own internal DC eco-circ pump.  First several attempts to do this failed.  There did not seem to be enough power coming from the solar panels.
     The process was very frustrating.  The eco-circ has its own built in controller that only takes as much power as is available from the solar panel and can supposedly run on as little as 8 watts.  Since I had a 20 watts of solar panels, it seemed like the pump should run.  The power from the solar panels was sent to both a charge control AND to the pump (switched through a relay).   My hope was that the charge control and the pump would each only take what they needed and share the power.  But this may have been a vain hope.  Even directly connecting the solar panel to the motor didn't seem to work.  I think there just is not enough power to get the motor started.  Even if the pump motor might be capable of running from 8 watts, perhaps it cannot start from 8 watts.
   So I needed a new plan.  One quick trip down to You-Do-It Electronics in Natick and I was back in business with a 50 W 24VDC power supply.  This did the trick and the pump started moving.  However, it was unreliable.
    Quickly I figured out that the problem was with air in the lines.  There are two air traps in the system which work great, except they can only do their job if the water is circulating.  Unfortunately, the water could not circulate because there was too much air in the lines.  Specifically, there was air trapped in the space where the motor impeller is located just before a check valve.  So there is a Catch 22.  The air traps cannot do their job if the water is not circulating but the water cannot circulate if there is air at the motor.

     By trial and error I found that by increasing the pressure  in the system (using the external charging pump) I could get the small circulator pump to start the water circulating.  The system has a flow meter with a glass window and massive quantities of air bubbles could be seen moving around.  Eventually, the bubbles worked their way to the air traps and could be purged from the system.  Then the some water was drained from the system to get the water pressure back down to about 12 psi.  All and all, I was happy to get to this point.  The system was holding pressure.  The water was circulating.  Not only is it circulating but it is circulating at more than 5 gpm (gallons per minute) which is twice the necessary 2.5 gpm.  Unfortunately it is taking 50 watts to get to 5 gpm, but hopefully it can get to 2.5 gpm for 25 watts.

    Clearly larger solar panels are needed so I ordered two 20 watt (40 watt total) solar panels from Amazon for $150 with $3.99 next day shipping..  Hopefully this will fix the issue with the pump.  I debated getting larger panels (like 60 watt total) but I really shouldn't need that much.


The Installation Tour

   So let me give you a tour of the installation now that it is almost complete.

The image above shows the South wall of my basement which contains most of the inside solar equipment.
1) Solar pumping station.  The front of this is the differential controller responsible for turning on and off the pump at the right time.  It is connects to thermistors (temperature sensors) on the solar panel and in the hot water tank.  Behind the controller is the pump and a large number of other components.
2) These Taco zone valves, when open, allow water (heat transfer fluid really) to flow to the hot water tank.  I doubled up on them to increase the amount of flow but in hind-sight this was probably unnecessary.  Although the connections to the valves are 1" the valve itself is probably less than 1/2".
3) These Taco zone valves, when open, allow water to flow to the heat dump.  Again they are doubled up.
4) This box contains A) charge controller, B) 24 V NiMH battery, C) 24 VDC to 12 VDC converter, D) some relays.
5) Some additional relays were needed to turn on the pump.  Unfortunately the controller is 12VDC but the pump is 24VDC so some relays were needed.
6) Expansion tank to take up the extra fluid when the water expanses when heated up.
7) These two pipes connect the pumping station to the solar panels
8) These two pipes connect the pumping station to the hot water tank.

  The picture above shows the 1/2 hp jet pump used for charging the system with fluid.  The fluid comes out of the bucket and is pumped into the solar system.  About 10 gallons is needed to fill the system.  The charging system is temporary and will be removed once the system is commissioned.

     The jet pump connects to the fill and drain ports on the solar pumping station (shown above) using garden hoses.
  Looking at the installation from another angle, we can see the solar pumping station (1) on the right, the piping (2) above, and the hot water tank (3) on the left.
       The overhead piping needed to be supported.  But most brackets would crush the insulation.  So I cut out a piece of aluminum (8x4"), painted it black, and placed it underneath the bracket to spread the load.  I also painted the bracket both black and white to match the insulation and ceiling as needed.
  
   On the other side of the room is the hot water tank.  The 80 gallon tank is manufactured right here in Massachusetts by Heat-Flo which is pretty cool.  There are a couple of nice things about the tank.  Firstly is that it is made of stainless steel which should assure a very long life time.  Secondly, all the connections are on the top of the tank which makes for a very clean installation. 
   The connections through the top of the tank were made through copper unions and full port valves. This setup allows the tank to be isolated from the rest of the system for servicing.
The wire for the thermistor was routed down the front face of the tank and secured with cable clamps that I pop-riveted to the plastic outer shell of the tank.

  Lastly, the solar PV panels were temporarily attached to the hot water panels using some 2x2" pressure treated lumber.  I felt there was a good chance that they would need to come off again, so I didn't attach them more permanently.  They will soon be replaced by larger panels and if those work out I will get some aluminum extrusions on which I will mount them more permanently.

  Next step, see if I can get Sweet Plumbing in to connect the hot water tank to the domestic hot water supply.